| Name | Score | Price | City |
|---|---|---|---|
| San Vito's Italian Bistro & Bar | 8.6 | $13.56 | Crystal Beach |
| Shaggy’s Pizza & Eats | 8.4 | $17.22 | Stevenville |
| South Coast Cookhouse | 8.2 | $21.47 | Crystal Beach |
| Rudders Restaurant | 8.2 | $21.46 | Sherkston |
| Vaticano Italian restaurant | 8.1 | $21.41 | Fort Erie |
| Da Vinci's Pizza & Wings | 8.1 | $15.85 | Fort Erie |
| 335 on the Ridge | 8.1 | $25.99 | Ridgeway |
| Papa's Pizza & Subs | 8 | $14.65 | Ridgeway |
| Bella Pizza | 7.9 | $16.81 | Ridgeway |
| The Barrel | 7.9 | $18.25 | Fort Erie |
| Aneta Pizzeria | 7.9 | $15.26 | Ridgeway |
| Zia's Pizzeria | 7.3 | $13.84 | Fort Erie |
| Masi Central Pizzeria | 7.2 | $13.55 | Fort Erie |
| Beach House Restaurant | 7.2 | $13.00 | Crystal Beach |
| Flying J | 6.9 | $19.20 | Fort Erie |
| The Plaice Bar & Grill | 6.8 | $16.89 | Fort Erie |
| Lighthouse Restaurant | 6.8 | $22.59 | Stevenville |
| Dominoes (Hand Tossed Crust) | 6.3 | $10.16 | Ridgeway |
| Pizza Hut (Flatbread) | 5.9 | $9.05 | Fort Erie |
| Avondale Food Stores | 5.9 | $14.85 | Fort Erie |
| Old Bank Bistro | 5.7 | $19.54 | Fort Erie |
| Sneakers Beach Tavern | 5.6 | $13.15 | Crystal Beach |
| Pizza Pizza (Cauliflour Crust) | 4.5 | $16.89 | Fort Erie |
| Little Caesars | 3.9 | $6.77 | Fort Erie |
| Mabels Gourmet | 0 | $0.00 | Crystal Beach |